Ivory-brick residence with an oak door, covered entry, bluestone steps, and mature tree canopy.

The Old Worthington Summer Everyone Waited Seven Years For

Oliver Chapman August 6, 2026

For most of the last decade, the two-story building at 649 N. High Street sat quiet. In the case of the historic Worthington Inn, "temporary" meant more than seven years, and the iconic building will become a restaurant and tavern again after closing in December 2018. That reopening happened this spring, and it changes what a Saturday in Old Worthington actually looks like from August through October.

If you already live here, you have watched the block adapt around a dark building. The farmers market kept running. Sunday Funday kept drawing crowds. Concerts on the Green filled the northwest quadrant every Sunday evening. All of it worked, but the anchor at the center of High Street was missing. It is back, and the calendar between now and Market Day is the first full season built around it.

What the Inn's return actually changes

The new version of the inn and restaurant, officially called Wolf's Ridge at Worthington Inn, comes after the beloved establishment closed in 2018. Wolf's Ridge Brewing opened the restaurant inside the historic Worthington Inn with a formal ribbon-cutting at 10 a.m. at the property, 649 N. High St. The ownership story matters if you care about who runs the businesses on your street. The building was purchased by 1831 Ventures, whose partners include Bob Szuter, his father and Wolf's Ridge co-owner Alan Szuter, Matt Sullivan, Sarah Perez, Worthington native Kat DePizzo and her husband, Jerry DePizzo, who plays saxophone and guitar in the rock band O.A.R.

The kitchen has a local pedigree too. The restaurant tapped Kris Ludwig, who previously worked at Wolf's Ridge Brewery downtown, as executive chef, with Brian Breslin joining as sous chef. The menu is tavern-first rather than fine-dining. Described as "approachable tavern fare," the menu features blonde French onion soup, a spring lettuce salad with herbs and sherry honey vinaigrette, fish and chips made with "Innkeeper beer-battered haddock" and the WRB burger with locally sourced beef.

A few practical notes for planning around it:

  • Hours run Monday through Thursday from 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m., Friday from 10:30 a.m. to 11 p.m., Saturday from 10 a.m. to 11 p.m. and Sunday from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m.
  • Final touches are still underway, and the restaurant is starting with reduced seating capacity; a lower level with a cocktail focus and a second kitchen is expected to open later, with no firm timeline.
  • Reservations are available, and walk-in customers are accommodated as the temporary capacity allows.

Read that last point twice if you are used to walking up on a Friday. For the first stretch of this summer, a text to a friend before you leave the house is the difference between dinner and a wait.

The Sunday that pulls it all together

The one calendar date to circle is August 9. Sunday Funday: Worthington End-of-Summer Fair runs 1 to 5 p.m. in Old Worthington at 671 High Street, with carnival games, two live bands, live entertainment, food specials at local restaurants, shopping specials, treats, and more treats, right before the kids head back to school.

That same evening closes out another tradition on the Village Green. Sunday evenings from May 17 to August 9 at 7:00 PM on the Northwest Village Green host Concerts on the Green, family-friendly performances spanning generations and genres, with parking available at the Griswold Center, Kilbourne Middle School, Worthington Library, Huntington Bank, and Worthington Presbyterian Church.

So the practical shape of August 9 is a carnival on High Street through the afternoon, a walk to whichever restaurant has the shortest line, and the final Civic Band concert of the summer on the northwest quadrant at 7 p.m. It is the only day of the year those three overlap.

Saturdays, from now through the leaves turning

The Worthington Farmers Market is not a new discovery for anyone who reads this. What is worth pinning down is exactly which Saturdays remain, because the schedule is every other week, not every week, and people miss it.

Saturday

Where

August 8

SR 161 and High St. corners

August 22

SR 161 and High St. corners

September 12

SR 161 and High St. corners

September 26

SR 161 and High St. corners

October 10

SR 161 and High St. corners

October 24

SR 161 and High St. corners

Fresh, local, and here since 1987. That longevity is the reason the market has kept its footprint at the intersection while everything around it has changed hands. It is also why Saturday morning parking near the Village Green disappears before 9:30. If you are grabbing coffee first, park east of High before you head in.

Third Thursdays and the point of DORA

There is a version of Old Worthington that only shows itself on the third Thursday of the month. On the third Thursday of every month, retail shops and boutiques stay open until 9 p.m., and restaurants serve drinks to sip on as you shop craft and art vendors along the street.

The DORA is the connective tissue that makes those evenings work. The DORA is every day, which means you can get a beverage to go and enjoy the shops and neighborhood. A short mental model for anyone who has not used it yet:

  1. Order in a cup from a permitted establishment.
  2. Walk. Stay inside the DORA boundary.
  3. Finish before you enter a business that is not participating, or before you cross out.

That is the whole rulebook. It sounds administrative in print. In practice it is why a Thursday evening feels less like an errand and more like a slow loop.

What comes after the fair

August 9 is the pivot. After it, the calendar shifts from summer routines to fall set pieces. Two are worth putting on the fridge now.

Harvest Fest, September 27. Harvest themed treats, food, games, beers, and all fun things harvest related, with food specials, live music, games, and entertainment, and the Parks Department hosting a farm themed petting zoo featuring a mini horse. The mini horse is not a metaphor. Bring the kids or someone who owes you a favor.

Old Worthington Market Day, October 3. High Street closes for the day for over 160 exhibitors featuring handmade arts and crafts, local charitable and civic organizations, food, live entertainment, and family activities from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. — Worthington's largest one-day festival and longest-running tradition.

Market Day is the one where out-of-town family always asks to come along. If you are hosting anyone in early October, hold the morning open before they ask.

One nearby opening worth logging

Old Worthington is the anchor, but the Worthington Woods stretch north of I-270 got a new dinner option this spring. Òrale Güey announced expansion to a second location, holding a grand opening on May 23 at 1175 Worthington Woods Blvd. The location is open all day with brand new evening menus. Worth knowing on a Tuesday when the High Street options feel over-familiar.

Why this stretch feels different

Old Worthington runs on repetition. The market comes back. The concerts come back. The parade comes back. The steady rhythm is what people mean when they say they like it here.

What resets the rhythm is a permanent change to what sits between the events. For seven years, the block worked around a closed building. This summer is the first one where the Inn is open on a Saturday morning when the market is set up outside, the first Third Thursday it is serving dinner, the first End-of-Summer Fair with lunch service two doors down. That is the thesis: it is not a new event calendar, it is the same calendar routed through a full block.

If you have walked past 649 N. High Street ten thousand times without going in, this is the season to change that. And if you have friends who moved away when the Inn closed, this is the visit that gets them back.

For neighborhood questions, home values, or a calm read on the Worthington market, reach out to Oliver Chapman. Let's Connect.

A Relationship-Driven Approach

Oliver Chapman is committed to building lasting relationships through honest communication, local expertise, and personalized service tailored to every client. From first-time buyers to experienced investors, clients receive dedicated support designed to simplify every step of the real estate process. Contact Oliver today to discuss all your real estate needs!