September 24, 2026
What do you do on a Tuesday morning when Jones Middle School starts in six minutes, the line at South of Lane runs past the sidewalk tables, and you have not had coffee yet?
South of Lane, the little counter-service cafe at 1987 Guilford Road, built its whole reputation on being a place people don't want to rush. The interior is small enough that regulars compare it to a European bistro. You order at the counter, get handed a number, and then the point is to sit with it. Sidewalk tables fill on weekend mornings and stay full, because nobody at South of Lane is in a hurry to give one up. Parking on Guilford is tight enough that longtime visitors have learned to circle onto Arlington Avenue instead. That slowness is the draw.
NBC4i reported on Coffee + Cone at 1966 N. Mallway Drive, which offers another option.
South of Lane earned its following the old-fashioned way: a small menu done well, repeated for years until it became a fixture. The BP2, a peanut butter and bacon waffle sandwich, and a scratch-made sweet potato hash are the dishes regulars mention first. The shop pours Thunder Kiss, a local roaster, and more than one visitor has left with a bag of beans because the smell alone sold them. None of that is built for speed. It's built for the kind of Saturday where you plan to be there a while, watching neighbors walk by on their way to the yoga studio or biking past on a morning loop.
That model works well for a sit-down visit. On weekdays, some people want coffee on the way to school drop-off or Devon Pool, or a quick stop rather than a table.
Coffee + Cone opened at the start of this year. It's owned by Alyssa Litzinger, who lives in the area, and the shop has minimal seating. As Alyssa Litzinger told NBC4i:
"We live nearby and there's a lot of great spots in Upper Arlington, but nothing quite like this. As a mom, I really wanted somewhere with great coffee, but also something for the kids."
The shop pours from One Line, a Columbus-based roaster, and keeps the menu split cleanly between espresso drinks and soft-serve builds, affogatos, shakes, sundaes, and a waffle-chip take on nachos. There are a few window seats. That's it. That leaves Coffee + Cone as a quick-stop alternative to South of Lane’s sit-down format.
It would have been easy for a new coffee shop to just compete with South of Lane head-on, same format, same slow mornings, same sidewalk tables, just newer. Instead the Mallway ended up with two shops that split the actual use case in half instead of duplicating it. South of Lane keeps the sit-down breakfast crowd that has no reason to leave. Coffee + Cone picks up everyone who needed caffeine five minutes ago: the school drop-off run past Jones Middle School, the pool bag already packed for Devon Pool, the dog walk that started ten minutes late.
That split matters more here than it would somewhere less walkable, because the two counters sit close enough to use interchangeably depending on the morning you're having. Litzinger has described the area in exactly those terms, calling it a very walkable and bike-friendly neighborhood near a couple of schools and a public pool. The geography does the work that a bigger single cafe never could: on a slow Saturday you pick South of Lane, on a rushed Tuesday you pick Coffee + Cone, and you don't have to leave the block to make either choice.
Compare that to what's happening a few minutes away on the broader Lane Avenue corridor, where Fox in the Snow opened its seventh Columbus location this past July, a location large enough to bring on roughly twenty-five employees. That's a different kind of growth entirely, a regional bakery chain planting a flag on a redeveloping commercial strip. The Mallway solved its own coffee shortage the opposite way: small, independently owned, sized to the block instead of the market.
The Mallway has always described itself as Upper Arlington's first commercial district, and the city's own framing of it leans on exactly the mix that makes the coffee situation work: a walkable area combining history and local businesses alongside public uses like Jones Middle School, Fire Station 71, Devon Pool, and the Veterans Memorial anchoring Mallway Park.
A short list of what sits within that same short walk:
That's not a list of amenities assembled for a brochure. It's the actual shape of a Tuesday morning here, and it has been for years. What changed in 2026 wasn't the neighborhood's character. It was the fact that, for the first time, the neighborhood has a fast lane running parallel to its slow one.
None of this required a redevelopment, a rezoning fight, or a chain moving in with plans to reshape the block. One shop added a second option to the Mallway. That's a smaller kind of news than a new mixed-use tower, but it's the kind that actually changes how a Tuesday morning goes for the people who live here, which is a better test of whether a neighborhood is working than almost anything else.
If you're watching Central Ohio neighborhoods for reasons that go beyond a coffee order, that same instinct, paying attention to how a place actually gets used day to day rather than just how it's marketed, is the same one worth bringing to a home search. Oliver Chapman spends his time in exactly these pockets of Dublin, Upper Arlington, Worthington, and Powell, and he's always glad to talk through what a neighborhood is really like once you've lived in it for a while. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Oliver Chapman is committed to building lasting relationships through honest communication, local expertise, and personalized service tailored to every client. From first-time buyers to experienced investors, clients receive dedicated support designed to simplify every step of the real estate process. Contact Oliver today to discuss all your real estate needs!