August 27, 2026
Two houses on the same Brookside street, both a short walk from Brookside Elementary and zoned to Worthington City Schools, can arrive at closing with different answers to a question most buyers never think to ask: who actually taxes this parcel?
The answer isn't always the same, even within blocks of each other. Most of Brookside sits inside Perry Township. A smaller pocket, informally known around the neighborhood as Brookside Estates West, was annexed into the City of Columbus decades ago. Both halves share the Worthington school boundary that gives the neighborhood its identity. Neither half shares a tax bill or a set of municipal services with the other.
For a buyer comparing two Brookside listings side by side, that split rarely shows up until a title company or an agent explains why the numbers on two seemingly identical homes don't line up.
Brookside grew up around Brookside Golf & Country Club, a private course founded in 1927 and laid out by Charlie Lorms, who had been the first golf professional at Columbus Country Club before designing his own 260 acres between State Route 315 and Sawmill Road. The surrounding subdivision, built out later in the mid-20th century by regional builder Bob Webb and others, has a country-club-adjacent identity.
What the club's history doesn't explain is the jurisdictional line running through the neighborhood built around it. Perry Township annexation and municipal boundary decisions made over the decades left most of Brookside under township governance while carving out a small western section that answers to Columbus city hall instead. The school district boundary was never redrawn to match. Worthington City Schools has continued serving both sides, which is why a listing can read "Worthington Schools, Perry Township taxes" in one breath and "Worthington Schools, Columbus taxes" in the next, describing homes that could sit within sight of each other.
Here's what that split actually changes for a household living in Brookside:
| Perry Township side | Columbus-annexed side | |
|---|---|---|
| School district | Worthington City Schools | Worthington City Schools |
| Taxing authority | Perry Township | City of Columbus |
| Property tax rate | Set by township levies | Set by Columbus city levies |
| Municipal services (trash, code enforcement) | Administered by the township | Administered by the city |
The school district column doesn't change. Everything below it does. A buyer who assumes "Brookside" means one uniform tax rate and one city hall to call with a service question can be surprised twice: once when the county duplicate shows a different levy structure than the comparable listing across the street, and again when they learn their trash day, their code enforcement contact, and their local government meetings all run through a different office than their neighbor's.
The clearest recent example of what township governance actually looks like on the ground came from the golf course itself. Brookside Golf & Country Club asked Perry Township's Board of Trustees for permission to install a driving range safety net along the practice facility, roughly 70 feet high and running more than 700 feet behind homes on Merwin Road. Franklin County's own road inventory confirms Merwin Road falls within Perry Township's jurisdiction, the same jurisdiction that had to weigh in before the club could build anything that size.
By September 2025, the club had scheduled separate meetings with the residents most directly affected by the range and with the broader Brookside Estates community, ahead of a trustees' hearing later that month. That's not how a project like this would move through a city council process, where a homeowner might expect a planning commission, a public notice period, and a single governing body handling both the zoning question and the neighborhood's broader municipal concerns. In a township, the Board of Trustees is that body, and its meetings are where a decision affecting sightlines and property values along one specific road gets made.
For anyone weighing a Brookside purchase on the Perry Township side, that's worth understanding before it matters: local land use decisions, from a golf course fence to a future road project, move through the township's trustees rather than a city council, and the notice and comment process looks different from what a buyer coming from a home-rule city might expect.
The jurisdiction question is easy to resolve if you know to ask it, and expensive to discover after the fact if you don't.
None of this is a reason to avoid Brookside. The neighborhood's draw, mature tree canopy, larger lots than much of the surrounding Columbus market, proximity to a nationally ranked private course, and a stable Worthington school boundary, holds regardless of which side of Merwin Road or Sawmill Road a given parcel sits on. The point is narrower: don't assume the neighborhood's name tells you everything about who taxes the home or who you'll be calling with a service question after you move in.
Does the tax jurisdiction affect my kids' school assignment? No. Worthington City Schools serves both the Perry Township and Columbus-annexed portions of Brookside. The boundary that matters for taxes and services is separate from the school boundary.
Is one side of the line better than the other for resale? Neither jurisdiction has shown a consistent resale advantage over the other in the research available here. The practical difference is in your monthly and annual carrying costs and which office you deal with for permits and services, not in long-term marketability.
How do I find out which side a specific address is on before I tour it? Ask your agent to pull the parcel from the county auditor's site, or request it directly. It takes a few minutes and it's worth doing before you fall in love with a specific house.
Brookside rewards buyers who ask a few more questions than the listing sheet answers. If you're comparing homes here, or anywhere else in Worthington, Dublin, Upper Arlington, or Powell, and want someone to walk the tax and jurisdiction details with you before you write an offer, Oliver Chapman has spent years working these specific Central Ohio boundaries. Let's connect.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Oliver Chapman is committed to building lasting relationships through honest communication, local expertise, and personalized service tailored to every client. From first-time buyers to experienced investors, clients receive dedicated support designed to simplify every step of the real estate process. Contact Oliver today to discuss all your real estate needs!